Star Bores, Episode Twee:
(Insert Phonetically Similar Mockery Here)
But
why do the wall-to-wall brown bathrobes in episodes I & II make these films only slightly more entertaining than an empty Pez dispenser? It's certainly not the caliber of actor hired to play them, although I'll be buggered as to why they seem to have been directed to act exactly like planks of pressure treated lumber. Nor is it for lack of lightsaber fighting. (I sometimes wish that the fight choreography of episodes IV through VI was even half as intricate. Alas, as is it's a lot of people talking very sternly to one another over crackly flourescent tubes.) No, the problem with the Jedi as central story is simpy that they aren't
human.
A JEDI SHALL NOT KNOW ANGER,
And neither shall you. I don't mean "human" in the literal sense, as in "they're a bunch of frickin' aliens!" Obi-Wan Kenobi, Anakin Skywalker, and "Shaft" Windu are all quite human. (Although if one
really wanted to get picky, the odds of there being actual
homo sapiens in "a galaxy far, far away" are roughly equivalent to your chances of getting good Thai food in South Jersey. But I digress.) Beyond mere physiology, the Jedi have removed themselves from experiencing the strong emotions that color most human experience. This is what keeps them from being interesting enough to sustain an entire movie, let alone a trilogy.
NOR HATRED,
The Jedi don't allow themselves to feel strong emotion. That's great. A little hard to relate to, but not unprecedented. There are elements of this pursuit in Zen Buddhism, which George Lucas borrowed when creating the Jedi. The ultimate goal of Buddhism is the elimination of suffering, which can be caused by things like desire and fear. But you don't generally see Buddhist monks giving up the pursuit of Nirvana to escort Queen Elizabeth around at the behest of the U.N. The Jedi don't seem to have any overriding goal other than becoming more intimate with the Force, and they seem happy to put that on hold while they go chop shit up with their lightsabers. They never really explain
why it's necessary to divest oneself of feelings. Yeah, I know, fear leads to anger leads to hate leads to suffering leads to the Dark Side. But don't forget
NOR LOVE
Love leads to... um. Hugs! Love leads to hugs, and hugs lead to cuddling, and cuddling probably leads to kissing, and then before you know it you've gone right to third base, and everybody knows that heavy petting = the Dark Side. So love is right out, wouldn't you say? But wait, doesn't Luke love Leia, even once he stops making out with her long enough to figure out that they're brother and sister? And doesn't he express intense affection for... well, pretty much everybody except fishy-faced Admiral Ackbar? Yes, he does. But that was in the original trilogy. In the new movies, love is
verboten for Jedi, right along with fear, anger, hatred, suffering, and pie. (Okay, pie is probably allowed.) The point is, that makes them entirely unlike anyone you've ever met. True, Buddhists try to meditate themselves beyond the need for emotional attachments less ambitious than loving
all of existence, but you know what? No one is clamoring for a movie about Buddhist monks. Unless Chow Yun fat is putting on the saffron robes and kicking some ass, the pursuit of enlightenment, no matter how intriguing or admirable, doesn't make for an exciting story. Why do you think the things that turn you on the most are the lightsaber fights? Because that's the only time that anything's happening. The rest of the movies could have been made with cardboard cutouts.
A good story has to involve the audience. You don't always have to like the characters (no, not even the protagonist), but you have to at least be interested in what happens to them. If they can't experience the emotions that you feel on a daily basis, your ability to understand and identify with them goes right out the window, especially if their daily life involves things that are entirely out of the scope of your experience, i.e. flying cars, telekinesis, and galactic conquest. By making the Jedi the focus of these films, Lucas has saddled us with characters whose shunning of emotion makes them more alien than any of the fantastic creatures populating his long lost galaxy. Luckily, George, and his audience, can rely on his clever writing and innovative direction to infuse these characters with a vibrancy that transcends their inherent alien calmness and brings them to life for the audience.
Oh. Crap.